How AI Search Is Recommending Reverse Mortgage: Monthly Trends

Executive Summary

Guild Mortgage leads the October 2026 reverse mortgage category in valid recommendation coverage at 49.3%, the highest reading any brand has posted across the July-to-October series. Guild's current position is up 1.7 points from its July baseline of 47.6%, a gain that falls within the range the benchmark treats as normal variation. Longbridge Financial holds second place at 43.8%, 5.5 points behind the leader, with Finance of America Reverse close behind in third at 43.4%, 5.9 points off the pace. The category's leadership is unchanged: Guild Mortgage held the top spot in September at 43.5% and remains there in October.

The strongest upward mover with meaningful coverage is Fairway Independent Mortgage, up 5.7 points from September's 29.4% to 35.1% in October, recovering to fifth place. That single-month gain remains within normal variation and reverses only part of the brand's baseline-to-current decline from 42.6% in July. Finance of America Reverse also rose, gaining 3.8 points from 39.6% in September to 43.4% in October, and Longbridge Financial added 5.1 points from 38.7% to 43.8%. All three gains stayed inside normal variation.

Liberty Reverse Mortgage is the month's sharpest decliner on a baseline comparison, falling 4.0 points from 7.1% in July to 3.1% in October, a significant move flagged by the benchmark. The brand slipped only 0.4 points from September to October. On a month-over-month basis, the largest gain among the larger brands was Fairway Independent Mortgage's 5.7-point rise; Mutual of Omaha Mortgage also gained 2.1 points since September, to 34.0%, even though it remains down 6.9 points from its July baseline.

October was a quiet month at the category level: no brand recorded a significant month-over-month movement, and the benchmark's only significant baseline-to-current change is Liberty Reverse Mortgage's decline. Against the July baseline, nine of ten tracked brands are classified stable. The October result confirms that the category's top tier has re-formed around Guild Mortgage, Longbridge Financial, and Finance of America Reverse, while the mid-tier brands remain below their July levels.

Each monthly run begins with 757 prompt-surface observations (488 unique questions) in October across the benchmark's defined AI/search surface universe, compared with 771 prompt-surface observations (484 unique questions) in September and 710 prompt-surface observations (410 unique questions) in July. Of the October prompts, 757 mentioned a tracked brand or competitor; 523 were relevant and 234 were irrelevant. The public metrics use the 288 qualified observations in October, down from 313 in September and 296 in July.

Key Findings

AI Response Inconsistency Alerts

Questions This Section Answers

• Which reverse mortgage brands generated the most AI factual inconsistencies this month?
• Where did AI platforms disagree about AAG's business status?
• What conflicting 2026 HECM loan limit figures appeared across platforms?

The October 2026 benchmark detected 10 critical and high-severity factual inconsistencies across six AI platforms: ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews, and Perplexity.

American Advisors Group (AAG)

Six critical and high-severity inconsistencies involve American Advisors Group (AAG), centred on the brand's current business status. When asked, "Is AAG a reputable company?", Perplexity stated that "the BBB profile for the former AAG entity now says it is out of business," citing the Better Business Bureau profile, a Consumer Financial Protection Bureau newsroom page, and Glassdoor. Gemini stated in response to the same question that "AAG continues to operate as a dominant brand in the industry," citing Retirement Living, Reverse Mortgage Alert, and Good Financial Cents. Both answers were returned for the identical query, and both carried critical severity at 0.95 confidence.

A second critical inconsistency on the same topic compared the same Perplexity claim of AAG being out of business against ChatGPT, which stated that "AAG appears to be a legitimate, established lender, now operating as a division of Finance of America Reverse." ChatGPT cited ConsumerAffairs, while the flagged source excerpts on the operating-entity side included Banks.com describing "AAG, a division of Finance of America Reverse LLC" and Bills.com describing AAG Reverse as a professional and experienced lender.

A third critical inconsistency contrasted the same Perplexity out-of-business claim with Copilot, which stated that "AAG is reputable and well-established in the reverse mortgage space," citing Retirement Living, ConsumerAffairs, and Glassdoor. Flagged sources supporting the Copilot position included Banks.com describing AAG as "one of the top reverse mortgage lenders in the U.S." and Bills.com describing it as a recognized industry leader.

At high severity, a fourth inconsistency concerns AAG's status and acquisition. When asked, "Who is the most reputable reverse mortgage company?", Copilot listed American Advisors Group (AAG) as a current top reverse mortgage company with its own strengths, rates, and loan limits, citing CNBC, Money, and Mortgage-Info. Google AI Overviews, responding to the same question, stated that Finance of America Reverse absorbed American Advisors Group (AAG), citing Money, Zeitro, and Forbes. A flagged source on the Copilot side quoted Mortgage-Info listing AAG at number two with a 6.75% rate and $1.15M HECM and $2.5M jumbo loan amounts.

A fifth high-severity inconsistency again concerns company status. Asked, "What company is best for reverse mortgage?", Google AI Mode listed American Advisors Group (AAG) as a top lender by volume, implying independent operation, citing Money, Forbes, and Times Union. Gemini, responding to the same question, stated that Finance of America Reverse has absorbed American Advisors Group (AAG), citing Zeitro and Money.

A sixth high-severity inconsistency concerns BBB accreditation and rating. Asked, "Is AAG a reputable company?", Perplexity stated the BBB profile for the former AAG entity now says it is out of business and has no current rating. Copilot stated that the company "is accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and was a finalist for the BBB Torch Awards for Ethics in 2020," citing Retirement Living, ConsumerAffairs, and Glassdoor. Flagged sources on the Copilot side included Retirement Living noting full BBB accreditation and Bills.com citing an A+ BBB rating and National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association membership.

Finance of America Reverse

Two high-severity inconsistencies involve Finance of America Reverse, both concerning the 2026 HECM loan limit. When asked, "What is the best company to get a reverse mortgage?", Gemini stated the federal HECM limit stands at $1,249,125, citing Truss Financial Group and Zeitro. Copilot stated that FHA-insured HECM loans cap at $1.15M in 2026, citing Money, Mortgage-Info, and CNBC. A flagged source on the Copilot side quoted Mortgage-Info listing "$1.15M (HECM) / $4M (Jumbo)."

The second high-severity inconsistency on the same topic contrasted Google AI Mode, which stated the federal HECM limit is $1,149,825 for 2026, citing CNBC, Money, and Truss Financial Group, against Gemini, which again stated the limit stands at $1,249,125, citing Truss Financial Group and Zeitro. A flagged source on the Gemini side quoted The Mortgage Reports noting a national lending limit of "$1,249,125 for most areas in 2026." Three different 2026 HECM figures appeared across these responses.

Mutual of Omaha Mortgage

Two high-severity inconsistencies involve Mutual of Omaha Mortgage. When asked, "How can I contact Mutual of Omaha customer service?", ChatGPT provided the number 877-330-4066, citing the company's support contact page and its pay-my-mortgage page. Gemini provided 1-833-721-1001, citing the company's support contact page, Nicholson Insurance, and the LTC Policy Hub. A flagged source on the Gemini side quoted the company's own contact page listing "Customer Service (833) 721-1001."

The second high-severity inconsistency concerns the availability of standalone home equity loans and HELOCs. Asked, "Is Mutual of Omaha a good place to get a home equity loan?", Perplexity stated the company offers home equity options including HELOC and cash-out via Mutual of Omaha Mortgage, citing Credible, LendingTree, and Bankrate. Google AI Mode stated the company does not broadly originate traditional standalone second-mortgage home equity loans or standard HELOCs in most regions. Flagged source excerpts on the Perplexity side included CGAA and Banks.com describing a Mutual of Omaha HELOC offering, while a flagged source on the Google AI Mode side stated that "Mutual of Omaha only offers cashout refinancing, no home equity loans or HELOCs."

Benchmark Context

Questions This Section Answers

• How many prompt observations qualified for the October reverse mortgage benchmark?
• What separates the raw collection universe from the qualified benchmark set?

The report separates the raw collection universe from the qualified analysis set. Brand-level recommendation percentages are calculated within the qualified benchmark set.

The counts above define the public denominator; the metrics below describe how brands performed within it. August, an intermediate month, held 284 qualified observations drawn from 800 raw prompt-surface observations, and September, also intermediate, held 313 qualified observations drawn from 771 raw prompt-surface observations.

Benchmark-Level Metrics

The qualified surface breadth remained stable at six families across all four months. Recommendation-shaped answer share spiked in August at 52.1% before settling to 39.3% in September and 40.3% in October. The valid recommendation shortlist share, which fell to 68.1% in September, recovered to 71.9% in October while remaining 5.8 points below its July baseline.

AI Recommendation Trend

Questions This Section Answers

• Which reverse mortgage brands still moved beyond normal variation this month?
• How did the October rankings differ from the July baseline for the leading brands?

A Confirmed Top Tier Led by Guild Mortgage as the Field Regroups

Guild Mortgage holds the October lead at 49.3%, its strongest month on record in this series, with Longbridge Financial and Finance of America Reverse within a point of each other in second and third. No brand's month-over-month movement exceeded normal variation.

The category-level change came from the combination of several smaller movements rather than from any single dominant shift. The only change that exceeded normal month-to-month variation is Liberty Reverse Mortgage's decline measured against the July baseline; every other movement sits within the range the benchmark treats as ordinary variation.

What Changed This Month

Questions This Section Answers

• Why does Guild Mortgage lead on coverage while trailing on rank-one share?
• Did Fairway's October gain reverse its decline or only restore visibility?
• What made Liberty Reverse Mortgage the only significant baseline decline?

Guild Mortgage: Extends the Lead to a Series High

Guild Mortgage rose from 43.5% in September to 49.3% in October, a 5.8-point gain within normal variation, and moved 1.7 points above its July baseline of 47.6%. October is the brand's highest coverage reading across the four-month series.

Placement metrics are mixed. The top-three rate improved from 7.3% in September to 14.6% in October, roughly recovering its July level of 14.5%, while the rank-one rate rose from 1.3% to 3.8%, still below the July figure of 4.7%. Raw mention presence held near its high at 59.7%, against 58.8% in July.

Guild's coverage lead is broad-based rather than top-of-answer driven. The brand appears in the widest set of answers in the category, but Finance of America Reverse still takes first position in a far larger share of the observations where it appears.

Highest-priority diagnostic: Which prompt categories are expanding Guild's presence, and why does its rank-one share remain below its broad coverage rate?

Fairway Independent Mortgage: Partial Recovery From an Elevated Decline

Fairway Independent Mortgage climbed from 29.4% in September to 35.1% in October, a 5.7-point gain within normal variation. Even after the recovery, the brand remains 7.5 points below its July baseline of 42.6%.

The recovery was concentrated in rank-one placement, which rose from 0.6% in September to 0.7% in October, while the top-three rate fell from 8.0% to 7.3%. Raw mention presence improved from 35.1% to 40.6%, still below the July level of 48.6%. Valid recommendations rose from 92 in September to 101 in October.

Fairway's October gain restored some visibility without restoring placement strength. The brand has recovered partway from its steepest month while its top-three and rank-one rates remain far below their July levels, a divergence worth watching.

Highest-priority diagnostic: Is Fairway's October gain the start of a recovery or a single-month rebound within a longer decline, and which surfaces account for the improvement?

Finance of America Reverse: Strongest Rank-One Position in the Category

Finance of America Reverse rose from 39.6% in September to 43.4% in October, a 3.8-point gain within normal variation. The brand remains 2.6 points below its July baseline of 46.0% and now ranks third by coverage, down from second place in September as Longbridge Financial moved ahead of it.

Rank-one strength continued to build on a rate basis: the rate rose from 33.2% in September to 34.7% in October, even as the rank-one count slipped from 104 to 100, reflecting a smaller pool of qualified observations this month. The top-three rate of 43.4% equals the brand's overall coverage, meaning essentially every recommendation places it in the top three, and the average recommended rank improved to 1.24 in October from 1.459 in July.

Finance of America Reverse is the category's most decisive top-of-answer brand. Virtually every answer that recommends it places it first or in the top three, even though Guild Mortgage and Longbridge Financial reach a broader set of answers.

Highest-priority diagnostic: Which surfaces drive Finance of America Reverse's rank-one rate, and where does it lose coverage to Guild and Longbridge?

Longbridge Financial: Reverses to Second Place on a Strong Month

Longbridge Financial rose from 38.7% in September to 43.8% in October, a 5.1-point gain within normal variation, and moved from third place to second. The brand remains 2.8 points below its July baseline of 46.6%.

The rank-one rate posted a sizable baseline-to-current gain, rising from 2.7% in July to 8.0% in October with rank-one count up from 8 to 23. The top-three rate improved from 36.1% to 42.0%, and valid recommendations rose from 121 in September to 126 in October. Raw mention presence edged up from 47.0% to 53.1%.

Longbridge closed the gap to the leaders on the strength of top-of-answer placements rather than mere presence. Its rank-one gain is the only notable positive placement movement in the series, and it now sits between Guild and Finance of America Reverse in overall coverage.

Highest-priority diagnostic: Which prompts produced the jump in rank-one placements, and does that placement strength hold in November?

Liberty Reverse Mortgage: The Only Significant Baseline Decline

Liberty Reverse Mortgage posted the only significant baseline-to-current change in the category, falling 4.0 points from 7.1% in July to 3.1% in October. The month-over-month move from September was only 0.4 points lower and stayed within normal variation.

Raw mention presence fell from 8.1% in July to 3.8% in October, a significant 4.3-point drop, while the top-three rate rose slightly from 1.0% to 1.7%. Valid recommendations fell from 21 in July to 9 in October. Rank-one rate was 0.0% in both months. This is a move from a small base: 9 valid recommendations in October against 21 in July.

This is a significant movement carried by a small count, and the absolute figures should be read alongside the percentages. Liberty retains a modest top-three presence even as its overall recommendation footprint has narrowed.

Highest-priority diagnostic: Which surfaces stopped surfacing Liberty, and does the November run confirm the October level or extend the decline?

All Reverse Mortgage, Mutual of Omaha Mortgage, and Smaller Brands: Movements Within Normal Range

All Reverse Mortgage declined from 14.9% in July to 11.1% in October, a 3.8-point drop within normal variation and its second consecutive month of decline. Its rank-one rate fell from 3.0% to 1.4% while its top-three rate edged up from 4.7% to 5.2%; valid recommendations fell from 44 in July to 32 in October.

Mutual of Omaha Mortgage fell from 40.9% in July to 34.0% in October, down 6.9 points within normal variation, though it gained 2.1 points from September. The brand's rank-one rate fell sharply from 8.5% to 2.1%, with rank-one count dropping from 25 to 6, even as its top-three rate improved from 24.7% to 27.8%; valid recommendations fell from 121 in July to 98 in October.

Open Mortgage fell from 0.7% in July to 0.0% in October, down 0.7 points, with no presence in any qualified observation this month after recording 2 valid recommendations in July. HighTechLending held flat at 1.4% with 4 valid recommendations, matching its July baseline. American Advisors Group (AAG) slipped 0.2 points from 3.0% to 2.8% while registering the category's lowest net sentiment reading at roughly 0.2, and its rank-one rate rose from 0.0% to 0.4% with a count of 1.

For these brands the absolute counts carry the meaning. Open Mortgage's move to zero presence and AAG's low sentiment reading are the two details most worth a closer look, and Liberty, HighTechLending, and Open Mortgage all operate on counts small enough that individual observations change the percentages materially.

Highest-priority diagnostic: For Open Mortgage, whether zero presence reflects a genuine loss across all surfaces or a distribution effect; for AAG, which prompts produce the low sentiment reading.

Buyer-Intent Interpretation

Questions This Section Answers

• Which buyer-intent clusters did the October observations actually cover?
• What reverse mortgage questions can this benchmark not yet answer?

In October 2026, all 288 qualified observations fell into the Brand Recommendation cluster, consistent with every prior month in the series. The benchmark therefore captures which brands AI systems recommend for reverse mortgage queries, but it cannot yet answer commercial questions about pricing, value, or head-to-head comparison. The October collection included 7 pricing analysis responses and 9 comparison analysis responses, but these did not qualify as separate buyer-intent clusters. The public benchmark's ability to answer price and comparison questions remains limited by this distribution.

Brand Opportunity Summary

Questions This Section Answers

• Which reverse mortgage brands carry the most urgent diagnostic this month?
• What should each brand investigate to explain its October signal?

The benchmark identifies where attention is warranted; a company-level analysis is needed to explain why.

Evidence Behind the Benchmark

The aggregate metrics are built from prompt-level observations (query, surface, recommendation outcome, rank, sentiment, and citations where exposed). Company-level analysis can go deeper into prompt, competitor, surface, and evidence patterns. Source presence is not automatically treated as proof of causation.

About This Benchmark

This report is part of the LLM Authority Index AI Visibility Market Discovery research program.

• AI Visibility Industry Market Methodology
• AI Visibility Industry Market Metrics
• AI Visibility Industry Market Standards

Report-Specific Interpretation Notes

• Small-count movements: Liberty Reverse Mortgage, HighTechLending, Open Mortgage, and American Advisors Group (AAG) have small valid recommendation counts; their percentage movements should be read with the absolute counts in mind.
• Qualified denominator: All brand-level percentages are calculated within the 288 qualified observations for October, not the 757 raw prompt-surface observations collected.
• Directional analysis: Month-over-month movement identifies changes worth investigating; it does not by itself establish the cause of those changes.

Next Step

The Public Benchmark Shows Where a Brand Is Winning or Losing. A Company-Level Audit Shows Why.

Beneath the aggregate percentage sit the questions that matter: which high-intent prompts are won, which competitor appears in a brand's place when it loses, what attributes AI systems associate with each option, and which external sources shape those answers. The confirmed top tier of Guild Mortgage, Longbridge Financial, and Finance of America Reverse, the persistent rank-one strength of Finance of America Reverse, and the small-base decline of Liberty Reverse Mortgage each has a prompt-level explanation that the category benchmark does not expose.

A company-specific AI visibility audit maps those prompt, surface, competitor, ranking, sentiment, and evidence-source patterns into a prioritized visibility strategy.

Request an AI visibility audit