Malarkey Appears in 43.3% of AI Answers. Here's Our Five-Step Plan to Improve Its AI Visibility.
This report supports CiteWorks Studio's examination of how AI search is recommending Roofing Companies. For more detail, you can also read Roofing Companies: AI Visibility Discovery Index.
On this report
Browse sections
- Answer Capsule
- Current AI visibility
- What changed since last month
- Next Step
- Step 1. Measure
- Step 2. Make the website consistent
- Step 3. Align the external narrative
- Step 4. Optimize priority company pages
- Step 5. Publish around buyer questions
- Our 90-day action plan
- Methodology
- Our first three priorities
- Related research
- Learn More
Key Takeaways
- Malarkey is mentioned in 341 of 787 benchmark answers and recommended in 249, but it is rarely the first choice.
- The main fact-checking priority is resolving conflicting claims about Highlander impact and wind ratings against primary sources.
- The most cited company pages are the impact-resistance and product-overview pages, which should be reviewed first.
- Buyer questions focus on best-brand and highest-quality shingle comparisons, giving clear topics for new content briefs.
Answer Capsule
In November 2026, Malarkey appeared in 341 of 787 AI answers included in the Roofing Companies benchmark (43.33%). It received 249 recommendations (31.64%), with 41 Top 3 placements and 8 first-place recommendations. A mention means the company appeared in an answer; a recommendation means the answer affirmatively endorsed it.
Our plan compares the company with its competitors, checks conflicting AI claims against reliable sources, and identifies website pages, third-party sources and buyer questions to address. This edition establishes a research baseline. It does not claim a change from earlier editions measured on a different basis. Conflicting AI claims require verification before corrections are proposed.
Current AI visibility
Questions This Section Answers
- How do Malarkey mentions, recommendations and placements compare with its Roofing Companies peers?
Malarkey recorded 341 mentions (43.33%) and 249 recommendations (31.64%) across 787 answers included in the benchmark. Top 3 placements numbered 41; first-place recommendations numbered 8. Framing among its mentions was 283 positive, 58 neutral and 0 negative.
Rank | Company | Mentions | Mention rate | Recommendations | Recommendation rate | Top 3 | Top 3 rate | #1 | #1 rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | GAF | 757 | 96.19% | 353 | 44.85% | 325 | 41.30% | 201 | 25.54% |
2 | Owens Corning | 718 | 91.23% | 347 | 44.09% | 323 | 41.04% | 74 | 9.40% |
3 | CertainTeed | 711 | 90.34% | 346 | 43.96% | 306 | 38.88% | 65 | 8.26% |
4 | Malarkey | 341 | 43.33% | 249 | 31.64% | 41 | 5.21% | 8 | 1.02% |
5 | IKO | 282 | 35.83% | 131 | 16.65% | 17 | 2.16% | 11 | 1.40% |
6 | TAMKO | 210 | 26.68% | 81 | 10.29% | 11 | 1.40% | 7 | 0.89% |
7 | Atlas Roofing | 117 | 14.87% | 78 | 9.91% | 6 | 0.76% | 0 | 0.00% |
8 | Erie Home | 26 | 3.30% | 18 | 2.29% | 17 | 2.16% | 9 | 1.14% |
9 | Power Home Remodeling | 25 | 3.18% | 16 | 2.03% | 14 | 1.78% | 6 | 0.76% |
10 | DECRA | 10 | 1.27% | 5 | 0.64% | 0 | 0.00% | 0 | 0.00% |
Malarkey appears in a large share of benchmark answers and is endorsed in most of those appearances, which puts it in a strong second tier behind the three leading brands. The gap is not reach so much as position: it is named often but rarely placed at the very top of an answer.
That pattern matters because buyers scanning an AI answer see the first names offered. Malarkey benefits from broad familiarity but loses the decisive slot to larger competitors. The agency would track recommendation share and top placement as separate scorecard measures so progress in one is not mistaken for progress in the other.
What changed since last month
Questions This Section Answers
- How did Malarkey counts and coverage differ across the available monthly snapshots?
Metric | Nov 2026 |
|---|---|
Mentions | 341 / 787 (43.33%) |
Recommendations | 249 / 787 (31.64%) |
Top 3 recommendations | 41 / 787 (5.21%) |
#1 recommendations | 8 / 787 (1.02%) |
Only months with verified results are shown. Monthly sample coverage is listed in Methodology.
This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.
This edition is the first broad baseline, so the monthly figures describe a starting point rather than movement from a prior month. Earlier editions asked a narrower set of questions, which makes direct comparison misleading.
The practical consequence is that this month's numbers become the reference point for future editions. The agency would hold the question set steady and compare later results against this baseline, while noting that a different answer total on its own does not explain why counts or rates shifted.
AI recommendation trend
Observed recommendation rate (%), Nov 2026
- Malarkeyno changeNov 202631.64%
Separate selected monthly samples. Missing points are unavailable, not zero. Provider/prompt equivalence is unverified; rate movement does not demonstrate causation.
/ Take the next step
Want to Understand Your AI Citation Footprint?
We start every engagement with a full audit of how AI systems reference your brand today.
Measurable, Repeatable Programme
Build a durable foundation of credible citations that compounds over time and continues to influence AI answers as new queries emerge
Citation Architecture Review
Identify which high-authority community sources are and aren't working in your favour across AI platforms.
AI Visibility Audit
Understand exactly how LLMs are referencing your brand today and which sources are shaping those answers.
Step 1. Measure
Questions This Section Answers
- What should the agency measure and verify first for Malarkey?
AI answers contained 6 conflicting claims about Malarkey: 0 critical, 1 high, 5 medium, 0 low. Of these, 1 was rated critical or high priority; the critical claims are included in that total. These ratings help prioritize fact-checking. They do not establish that a company or publisher made an error.
The research surfaced a small set of conflicting claims about Malarkey, and only one was rated high priority. That ranking gives the client a sensible starting order for fact-checking rather than a list to work through indiscriminately.
The agency would build a visibility comparison alongside a scoped fact-review register, assigning each disputed claim an owner and an evidence requirement. The register records what needs checking; it does not assert that any company or publisher got something wrong.
Step 2. Make the website consistent
Questions This Section Answers
- Which recorded claim differences about Malarkey should be verified before proposed page edits?
Review topic | Severity | Recorded AI claim A | Recorded AI claim B |
|---|---|---|---|
Highlander impact rating | medium | Class 3 impact rating | Class 4 impact rating |
wind rating | medium | up to 130 mph | up to 140 mph |
wind rating | medium | up to 130 mph | up to 140 mph |
Highlander impact rating | medium | Class 3 impact rating | Class 4 impact rating |
Both columns quote AI answers, not verified company facts. Resolve the entity, date and source before deciding whether a correction is warranted; different dates can explain an apparent conflict.
The disputed topics cluster around impact and wind ratings for the Highlander line, where recorded answers give different classes and different wind speeds. Both sides of each conflict are quoted from AI answers, not verified product facts.
The agency would verify the current primary sources first, including product dates, before drafting any page brief. Where the record supports a clear answer, a brief would set out approved wording; where it does not, the item stays open rather than becoming a correction request.
Step 3. Align the external narrative
Questions This Section Answers
- Which cited third-party pages are relevant to fact review for Malarkey?
Cited page selected for review | Citation appearances in all captured answers | Answers mentioning the company | Conflicting claims linked to this page |
|---|---|---|---|
https://happyroofing.com/blog/malarkey-roofing-products-review-pros-cons-comparison | 5 | 5 | 4 |
https://contractortalk.com/threads/malarkey-shingles.103576/ | 2 | 2 | 3 |
https://youtube.com/watch?v=Lhd92rf0U0Q | 4 | 4 | 3 |
https://youtube.com/watch?v=kZthwDozCAg | 3 | 3 | 3 |
https://youtube.com/watch?v=dnxbgyqCt2M | 2 | 2 | 3 |
https://facebook.com/groups/roofingindustry/posts/2617754031921600/ | 1 | 1 | 3 |
These pages were selected because they relate to the company in the captured answers. Their current contents still need checking before any correction request. A page linked to a conflicting claim is not necessarily its cause, and the same answer may contribute to more than one row.
A handful of third-party pages, including a review blog, a contractor forum and several videos, were cited alongside the conflicting claims. Citation does not show that a page caused the conflict, and the pages still need checking before anyone approaches a publisher.
The agency would review the most frequently cited sources first and prepare evidence-backed requests only where current contents genuinely conflict with verified facts. Forum and video material may warrant a lighter touch than an edited review page.
Step 4. Optimize priority company pages
Questions This Section Answers
- Which observed Malarkey website pages should receive review briefs?
Company website page | Citation appearances in all captured answers | Benchmark answers citing the page | Recommending answers citing the page |
|---|---|---|---|
https://malarkeyroofing.com/features/impact-resistance/ | 11 | 11 | 8 |
https://malarkeyroofing.com/ | 6 | 6 | 5 |
https://malarkeyroofing.com/class-4-impact-resistance-roofing-shingles/ | 3 | 3 | 1 |
https://malarkeyroofing.com/products/shingles-overview/ | 3 | 3 | 2 |
https://malarkeyroofing.com/products/shingles-overview/vista-ar-shingles/ | 3 | 3 | 3 |
https://malarkeyroofing.com/app/uploads/2026/03/roof-system-trifold-standard-malarkey.pdf | 2 | 2 | 2 |
https://malarkeyroofing.com/homeowners/why-malarkey/ | 2 | 2 | 2 |
https://malarkeyroofing.com/about-us/faq/ | 1 | 1 | 1 |
The company's website was cited 45 times across 22 distinct page addresses; the table shows 8 pages selected for review. Zeros in the answer columns mean no matching answers were recorded. A cited page is not automatically a page that accompanied a recommendation.
Malarkey's own site was cited across many pages, with the impact-resistance page appearing most often and often alongside recommending answers. That makes the impact and product-overview pages the natural focus for page briefs.
The agency would draft briefs using approved facts and the questions buyers actually ask, then check existing coverage before proposing anything new. A cited page is not automatically a page that drove a recommendation, so briefs would be prioritized by relevance rather than citation count alone.
Step 5. Publish around buyer questions
Questions This Section Answers
- Which observed buyer questions support content briefs for Malarkey?
Question observed in the research | Benchmark answers to this question | Company mentions | Company recommendations |
|---|---|---|---|
What is the best brand for roofing? | 6 | 6 | 5 |
What is the best roof shingle company? | 5 | 5 | 5 |
What is the best shingle brand? | 5 | 5 | 5 |
What is the highest quality asphalt shingle? | 6 | 5 | 5 |
What are the highest quality asphalt shingles? | 5 | 5 | 4 |
What is the best quality roof shingles? | 5 | 5 | 4 |
What are the best roofing shingles? | 6 | 4 | 4 |
What is the best brand of roof? | 5 | 4 | 4 |
These are recorded answer observations, not search volume, verified demand, or proof of missing website content.
The recorded questions are broad brand and quality comparisons, and Malarkey was mentioned and recommended in most answers to them. That suggests the brand is already in the consideration set for these buyer questions.
The agency would turn these observations into content briefs that answer the comparison directly, checking first whether existing pages already cover the ground. These are recorded answer observations, not search volume or proof that a page is missing.
Our 90-day action plan
Questions This Section Answers
- How should the agency sequence the proposed Malarkey work and judge completion?
Period | Deliverable | Completion criterion |
|---|---|---|
Days 1–30 | Baseline scorecard, scoped fact-review register and page/source shortlist | Each record has an owner, evidence requirement and review status |
Days 31–60 | Approved page briefs and justified publisher requests | Separate confirmed edits, no-change decisions, requests and responses |
Days 61–90 | Buyer-content briefs and a fresh scorecard | Record work completed separately from measured answer outcomes and comparability limits |
The first month establishes the baseline scorecard, a scoped fact-review register and a shortlist of pages and sources, each with an owner and review status. The second month produces approved page briefs and justified publisher requests, with confirmed edits and no-change decisions recorded separately.
The final month delivers buyer-content briefs and a fresh scorecard. Completed work would be reported separately from measured answer outcomes, since delivering briefs does not guarantee a change in visibility.
Methodology
Questions This Section Answers
- How are Malarkey answer metrics and citation populations defined?
This report covers 2026-11. The exact dates when the original AI answers were collected have not been verified. The visibility rates use 787 answers that met the benchmark's inclusion rules. A company is recommended only when the answer both endorses it and uses positive wording. Top 3 and first-place counts are part of those recommendations, not extra recommendations.
An answer can mention or recommend several companies, so company counts cannot be added to find the number of distinct answers. The net sentiment score is positive minus negative mentions, divided by all company mentions; it describes answer wording, not customer satisfaction.
The wider citation analysis covers 800 captured answers and 5566 appearances of cited URLs. Citation appearances across all captured answers differ from the number of benchmark answers citing a page and the number that also recommend a company. The current contents of cited pages and disputed company claims still need independent verification.
Monthly sample coverage:
Reporting month | Answers included | AI services covered | Services |
|---|---|---|---|
Nov 2026 | 787 | 6 | ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity |
August 2026 measured a different set of companies, so it is excluded from this comparison. Earlier editions (July 2026, September 2026 and October 2026) used a narrower set of questions. This edition includes all captured answers screened as relevant and establishes a broader baseline. Earlier figures remain in the archive; they are not used to claim a change in performance.
Future editions using the same screening scope can be compared against this baseline.
The visibility rates rest on answers that met the benchmark's inclusion rules, and a company counts as recommended only when an answer endorses it with positive wording. Top placements sit inside those recommendations rather than adding to them.
Answers can name several companies, so counts cannot be summed into distinct answers. The exact collection dates are unverified, cited page contents still need independent checking, and this edition's broader scope means earlier figures are not treated as a trend.
Our first three priorities
The most useful first step is verifying the impact and wind rating claims against current primary sources, since those conflicts touch a product line buyers compare directly. Until that check is complete, no correction request should go out.
Second, the agency would prepare page briefs for the impact-resistance and product-overview pages, using approved facts and buyer questions. Third, it would draft comparison content for the broad brand and quality questions where Malarkey already appears, confirming existing coverage before proposing new pages.
Related research
This report supports CiteWorks Studio's examination of how AI search is recommending Roofing Companies. For more detail, you can also read Roofing Companies: AI Visibility Discovery Index.
/ Learn More
Understanding AI search visibility.
AI search experiences create answers by pulling information from many places online and summarizing it into a single response.


